Brand
Vintage
& Varietal or Type
Appellation -$ price
|
Consensus
Tasting Notes
|
#Rank
Buying
Advice
|
|
Roederer
Estate
(nv) Brut
Anderson
Valley -$18.00
|
Clean aroma with
a hint of yeastiness; complex, controlled
apple-like flavors with a creamy and persistent
mousse; very harmonious balance and a medium-long
finish. A clear winner.
|
#1
Very
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Domaine
Carneros
1995 Brut
Napa -
Carneros -$18.00
|
Clean aroma with
a hint of flint; very light mouthfeel and pleasing
flavors with a nice lemony tartness; tiny and very
persistent bubbles. Probably would show well
matched with light foods.
|
#2
Very
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Pacific
Echo
(nv) Brut
Mendocino
-$15.
|
Clean, slightly
fruity aroma with touches of almond, vanilla, bread
dough or toast; nicely layered, although light
flavors are smooth, round, soft; low acid;
pleasant, somewhat short finish.
|
#3
Very
Highly
Recommended
|
|
J
1995
Sonoma County
-$25.
|
Very light aroma,
slightly flinty; very clean, very light, floral and
faintly citrussy flavor; balance is almost sweet;
very persistent and tiny bubbles and a
medium-length finish.
|
#4
Highly
Recommended
|
|
S.
Anderson
1995 Brut
Napa Valley
-$21.
|
Faint vanilla
aroma with initial matchstick; very rich, soft
mouthfeel with pleasant citrus and tart apple
flavors, almost sweet/sour; medium-full bodied;
harmonious balance and good length
|
#5
Recommended
|
|
S.
Anderson
1985 Brut (Late
Disgorged)
Napa Valley
-$30.
(winery only)
|
Full, yeasty,
leesy, toasty, baked apple, complex aromas; very
big and flavorful with elements of yeast, minerals,
apples and hints of Amaretto, oak and caramel; very
rich; good length. Very well-developed older
style.
|
#6
Recommended
(although
stylistically controversial)
|
|
Jepson
(nv) Blanc de Blanc
Burney Hill
Vnyd, Mendocino -$17.
|
Big, ripe, fruity
aroma with a sweet, floral and banana peel
(linalool) character; unusual sweet and sour and
perfumey flavor; very lively bubbles.
|
#7
Recommended
(although controversial)
|
|
Jepson
1994 Blanc de Blanc
Burney Hill
Vnyd, Mendocino
-$17.
|
Aggressive,
yeasty, toasty, somewhat cheesy aroma; complex
segmented flavors mix cheese, coffee, rye, almonds,
apples, honey and citrus; slight bitterness and
noticeable acescence mar finish.
|
#8
Recommended
(although
controversial)
|
|
Jepson
1992 Blanc de Blanc
Mendocino
-$17.
|
Obvious fruit,
with vanilla, yeast and bread dough aromas;
expansive, almost "thick" mouthfeel; very light
green apple, caramel and toast flavors show some
oxidation; clean, crisp, but short
finish.
|
#9
Recommended
(although
controversial)
|
|
One additional bottle was
distinctly "corked" and therefore not rated.
Although not previously noted, this was our fourth
tasting out of the past ten where a bad cork ruined
a bottle. This problem has increased over the past
decade and is no longer tolerable. PfW gives its
wholehearted endorsement to synthetic corks, in
hopes the wineries are listening...
|
This
panel included Deanna, Glenn, Diana, Roy, Marlene,
Jon, Jim, Chris, Ron, and Greg.
About
Sparkling Wine
|