|
HOME
> TASTING
NOTES > CABERNET
FRANC
This
turned into one of the most amazing and interesting
tastings PfW has held. Conceived as a joint venture with
Tablewine.com (compare their results: "Francly
Speaking"),
we chose Cabernet Franc as a varietal that frequently
shares the spotlight with its more popular offspring,
Cabernet Sauvignon, but rarely gets attention on its own.
Jon's hospitality and cuisine were both superb. The line
up covered a fair span of appellations and the broadest
possible spectrum of price and brand caché. In
fact, an entirely
separate article
is necessary to detail and analyze the ramifications and
implications of our pleasure!
|
Brand
Varietal
or Proprietary
Type
Vintage
& Appellation
$ price - alcohol
content
|
Compilation
Tasting Notes
(bold
type = consensus; ? = flaw?)
[technique,
if known]
|
#Rank
Buying
Advice
|
|
La
Jota
1988 Cabernet
Franc
Napa "Howell
Mountain"
$30. -
?%
|
Deep
ruby color with a hint of garnet; attractive aroma
mingles pine, orange peel, spice, licorice,
violets, berries, oak; elegant,
well-integrated, round, slightly oaky
flavors, could use more fruit; balanced,
slightly tart (bitter?); assertive tannins,
astringent; long, pleasant finish. Excellent
showing of a well-cellared wine.
|
#1
Very
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Justin
1996 Cabernet
Franc
Paso
Robles
$29. - 14.1%
|
Deep
plum color; big aroma, complex with plum,
bell pepper, roasty-toasty, tar, coconut,
American oak (too oaky?), fruity,
aromatic (ethyl acetate?); rich, ripe
flavors (overripe?) are similar, somewhat
disjointed; balance is quite tart, snappy;
smooth tannins in a tart, pleasant finish.
Cellar time may help bring this together.
[100%
varietal, 41 months in American oak]
|
#2
Very
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Sinskey
1995 Cabernet
Franc
Carneros,
Napa
$27. - 14.1%
|
Deep
plum color; complex,
cedar, vanilla, tar, earth, spice, salami, oak,
very ripe, port-like (some ethyl
acetate?); tight, extracted fruit, juicy,
spicy, somewhat hard, hollow flavors; very good
balance; drying tannins, but not big.
Overblown style, but very well done.
[1000
cases produced]
|
#3
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Ravenswood
1998 Cabernet
Franc
Sonoma
County
$12.50 - 13.6%
|
Deep
plum color; young, grapey, cassis, rich,
deep blackberry fruit, clean (albeit
two comments of faint earthy or yeastiness); big
monster, youthful, very ripe, pleasant
cherry fruit flavors, dominated by tannins;
long, but slightly rough finish (stemmy?).
Much improved with food, might improve with
cellaring.
|
#4
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Pepperwood
Grove
1998 Cabernet
Franc
California
$6. - 12.5%
|
Medium
plum-garnet color; vanilla, cassis, faintly tarry,
smoky, herbal-bordering on vegetal, spicy
(older?); big cassis fruit flavor, somewhat jammy,
not varietal (tastes more like a blend than
other wines), some stemminess; medium body, some
richness; good balance, faintly tart; soft
tannins, short finish. Pleasant, but not varietally
distinctive.
|
#5
Highly
Recommended
BEST
BUY
|
|
Cosentino
1998 Cabernet
Franc
Napa
Valley
$35. - 14.5%
|
Deep
ruby-plum color; complex, licorice, plums,
spicy, vanilla, perfumey, sweet
wood, oak; simple flavors are
oaky, similar to nose, rich, fair
depth; medium-full body; balance okay (too sweet?);
fairly soft tannins; slight heat and
bitterness in long finish.
[unfined,
hand punched-cap, open fermentation]
|
#6
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Gundlach-Bundschu
1998 Cabernet
Franc
Sonoma
Valley
$15. - 14.0%
|
Deep
ruby color; clean, attractive, ripe, sweet, young,
subdued blackberry, cherry
fruit, with cocoa, some toasty, smoky hints;
good flavors, similar to nose, woody,
slightly hollow in middle; fairly well-balanced;
medium body; gripping tannins; medium-long finish.
Taste improved noticeably with food.
|
#7
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Ch.
Cheval Blanc
1981 St.
Emilion
(French Bordeaux)
$115. to
$225. (current)
|
Deep
garnet with brickish edge;
initially
closed in, complex, cocoa powder, herbs, bell
pepper, with a slightly gamey (brett?),
earthy element, slightly woody; rich, warm,
leathery flavors; medium tannins; good balance,
slightly lean; long, drying finish.
[approx.
66% Cabernet Franc, 33% Merlot, 1% Malbec, 20
months in barrels]
|
#8
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Ch.
Cheval Blanc
1985 St.
Emilion
(French Bordeaux)
$185. to
$460. (current)
|
Deep
garnet with brickish edge; subtle plum
fruit, opulent, complex with herbs, spice, bacon
fat, bell pepper, pine, earth,
brettanomyces, some leesy elements;
gamey, cumin, caramel and earthy, brett
flavors dominate lean fruit; good
balance, faintly tart; soft, smooth,
short, earthy finish (tired?).
[approx.
66% Cabernet Franc, 33% Merlot, 1% Malbec, 20
months in barrels]
|
#9
Highly
Recommended
|
This
Panel
included Regulars Roy, Marlene, Jon, Ray,
Jim, Ron, & James
About
Cabernet Franc
|
|