|
HOME
> TASTING
NOTES >
SYRAH
We explored California
Syrah, as distinct from Petite Sirah, Australian Shiraz,
etc. The overall effect of this tasting was to decide
that we simply are not drinking enough of this varietal.
Syrah offers very enjoyable and unique complexities and
the general level of quality displayed by this group of
wines was excellent, with some great value "sleepers".
They partnered well with the selection of cheeses and
grilled sausages Chris Mariscotti served to
accompany.
Brand
Vintage
& Varietal or
Type
Appellation
-$ price
|
Consensus
Tasting Notes
|
#Rank
Buying
Advice
|
|
Ojai
1996 Syrah
Santa Barbara
- $35.
|
Very dark purple;
very ripe, orange peel, and dried fruit aroma with
noticeable earth, alcohol, toast, smoke, barnyard,
seaweed and iodine elements; pleasing, blackberry
and roasted oak flavors with complexities of
mushrooms and minerals; medium to medium-full body,
quite rich; balanced; drying tannins; long, warm
finish.
|
#1
Very Highly
Recommended
|
|
Morgan
1997 Syrah
Monterey -
$18.
|
Somewhat lighter
color; fruity, earthy, cola, coffee, toasty, clove,
and spicy aromas, with hints of smoke, charcoal,
barnyard, and band-aids; sweet, raspberry, fruity,
faintly herbal (clove) flavors; light to medium
body, supple and slightly rich; good balance;
medium tannins; short, faintly harsh
finish.
|
#2
Very Highly
Recommended
|
|
Andrew
Murray
1997 Syrah
Santa Barbara
- $18.
|
Deep purple,
violet edge; cassis, beet, cola, berry, earth, and
cedar aromas with some bacon fat, roasted oak and
overripe hints of ethyl acetate and volatile
acidity; ripe, sweet, cherry and plum fruit
flavors, somewhat closed, slightly musty; balanced,
round; big, chalky tannins; astringent
finish.
|
#3
Very Highly
Recommended
|
|
Bell
1997 "Canterbury"
Napa Valley -
$28.
|
Dark purple;
black fruit, cherry, plum, earthy, musty, leathery,
coffee bean, cigar box, cedar, and charred aromas;
sweet, complex, cola, berry, chocolate, bacon fat
and ethyl acetate-touched flavors, tarry; balanced;
upfront tannins leave a somewhat disappointing
short finish.
|
#4
Very Highly
Recommended
|
|
R.H.
Phillips
1997 "EXP"
California -
$11.
|
Dark purple;
licorice, blackberry, cola,cassis, meaty, tobacco,
cedar, vanilla, and violet aromas; big, ripe,
young, clean, slightly oaky, blackberry fruit
flavors; rich, medium to medium-full body; good
balance; faintly bitter tannins in long
finish.
|
#5
Very Highly
Recommended
BEST
BUY
|
|
Pepperwood
Grove
1998 Syrah
California -
$6.
|
Medium purple;
bright, clean, direct, youthful, somewhat
Beaujolais-like, blackberry fruit aroma with some
wood and an odd element (burnt butter?); sweet,
slightly underripe fruit; light to medium body,
slightly rich; balanced; very pleasant and
quaffable.
|
#6
Highly
Recommended
BEST
BUY
|
|
Qupé
1996 Syrah
"Reserve"
Santa
Barbara, "Bien Nacido" - $34.
|
Medium purple,
brick edge; shy aroma with hints of black cherries,
cassis, earth, meat, bacon fat, barnyard, iodine,
smoke and rubber; pleasant entry, deep blackberry
and dried fruit flavors with roasted grain notes;
medium body with some richness; nicely balanced,
good structure; soft tannins, faint heat in
finish.
|
#7
Recommended
|
|
Qupé
1996 Syrah
"Reserve"
Santa Barbara
"Hillside Estate" - $30.
|
Medium purple;
cherry, clove, and black fruit aromas, smoky and
somewhat vegetal with a noticeable hydrogen sulfide
funk; cherry, tarry, slightly burned flavors;
medium body; balanced with good acidity; dusty
tannins; medium finish with a sweet
edge.
|
#8
Recommended
|
|
Jaffurs
1998 Syrah
Santa Barbara
- $20.
|
Deep purple,
violet edge; earthy, flowery, grapey, anise, and
tar aromas with hints of vanilla and eucalyptus;
similar fruity, faintly herbal, black fruit and tar
flavors; medium body with some richness; soft,
chunky tannins; medium finish.
|
#9
Somewhat
Recommended
|
|
Sobon
Estate
1997 Syrah
Shenandoah
Valley - $12.
|
Medium purple,
crimson edge; vinous, smoky, and sour with some
initial hydrogen sulfide and burnt rubber stench;
sweet, dried cherry, raspberry, and basil flavors
are somewhat thin, slightly stemmy; medium body;
flabby balance; dusty, chalky, slightly bitter
tannins.
|
#10
Not
Recommended
|
This
Panel
included Regulars Mark, Deanna, Diana,
Roy,
Marlene, Jon, Jim, Chris, Ron, and
James
About
Syrah
|
|